Thrift Store Jewelry: How To Find Fine Jewelry For Resale

Thrift Store Jewelry
Thrift Store Jewelry: How To Find Fine Jewelry For Resale

My Fine Jewelry Treasures Found Among Thrift Store Junk! #thriftstorejewelry #jewelry #resale #finejewelry #tiffanyjewelry #ruralmoney #rural #money

You can find fine thrift store jewelry at thrift stores, but most shoppers don’t know how to spot the real stuff that has resale value.

Disclaimer: I am an Amazon Associate and Influencer; therefore, this post may contain affiliate links for me to earn a commission. RuralMoney.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Shop with me for less >>>here.

Table of Contents

The fact is many people have fine gems in their jewelry boxes that they never wear, which have resale value, yet end up donated to local charities.

Perhaps, it was a gift that didn’t really suit their style.

Or, this may have been a piece of jewelry inherited from a distant family member that didn’t hold much sentimental or aesthetic value for them.

Case in point, I recently paid $20 for a 1969 ‘PLEASE RETURN TO TIFFANY & CO. NEW YORK 925’ Sterling Silver Dog Collar Necklace at a thrift store (see description and retail/resale value below).

I have also listed several other pieces of jewelry purchased in the same haul.

More often than not, valuable pieces of jewelry are misidentified as junk or fake and sold for $1 to $20.

When you know how to find fine jewelry at thrift stores, these pieces can be flipped for quick, extra cash.

Here are some in-demand categories in resale jewelry, along with advice on how to sell it.

How To Find Fine Jewelry At Thrift Stores Such As Vintage, Retro, Bakelite?

American and European jewelry that’s older that 50 years, but newer than 100 years is considered vintage.

Of this range, pieces from the 1920s to 1940s Art Deco period are in very high demand.

Streamlined, angular, très chic Art Deco jewelry still looks cool today.

Many of the most celebrated names in jewelry and fashion, including Cartier, Tiffany and Van Cleef & Arpels, came into their own during the Art Deco period.

Therefore, it isn’t surprising that pieces from these brands command top prices on today’s market.

The Deco period also gave rise to a lot of mass-produced jewelry, which is very much in demand today.

As much of the Deco period coincides with the Great Depression of 1929 to 1939, department stores found ways to market more affordable jewelry that was still quite stylish.

At the time, one of the key materials they used to achieve this goal was a brand-new synthetic wonder resin called Bakelite.

It could be easily molded, with vivid colors ejected directly into the resin, and was used as a kind of a cheap and cheerful alternative to precious metals or stones.

Native American Jewelry Is Hot If You Can Find It

It pays to know your gemstones because there is a vigorous online international market for Native American jewelry as well.

However, you must do your homework if you want to obtain top dollar for what you have to sell.

Rural Money Tip:   Don’t take it to a pawnshop because they’ll buy it for the meltdown value of any precious metals contained in the piece. In my experience, pawnshops aren’t that educated, and a certain piece could be worth a lot more just because of the person who made it.


Hopi jewelry in general really sells the best with beautiful silver overlay work, without a lot of precious or semi-precious stones.

On the other hand, Navajo turquoise work is also a big seller.

The best resale pieces were made for tribal or ceremonial purposes.

As a general rule, handmade is much more valuable than anything machine made.

According to the experts, if you want to sell your stuff, don’t clean it because collectors like “patina.”

Where To Sell Fine Jewelry From Thrift Stores?

Etsy, Ruby Lane, eBay, Poshmark and Paul Fraser are good online platforms for selling vintage jewelry.

This is the description of my 1969 ‘’PLEASE RETURN TO TIFFANY & CO. NEW YORK 925’ Sterling Silver Dog Collar Necklace for possible resale.

TIFFANY & Co. Vintage Sterling Designer Necklace

Measurements: 16” L x 0.75″ W x 0.38″ H

Weight: 55.2 grams

Condition: Gently used, tarnish and dirt from years of storage. Any Tiffany shop will clean and give it the TLC to return it to as close its original condition as is possible for free!

Thrift Store Price: $20

Retail Value: $1500

Resale: $650 (Shipping Included)

Description:  This choker length necklace is from the ‘Return to Tiffany’ line that Tiffany still makes. It has the oval tag that was the original 1969 design and Tiffany brought it back recently, selling out in days! It is Sterling Silver, links with an oval shaped tag in the front that reads ‘PLEASE RETURN TO TIFFANY & CO. NEW YORK 925’ and large Sterling Silver lobster claw clasp, which attaches to the tag in the front of the necklace. It comes with its original suede drawstring pouch and box! This is an authentic piece from the original run, which is why the price is higher than other used pieces you will see online.

Other vivid, vintage inspired jewelry pieces acquired during my recent thrift store jewelry haul include:

  • Peridot 5.0 Carat Oval Faceted 925 Ring $4
  • Morganite (Possibly) 5.0 Carat Princess Faceted with 2 Emerald Faceted CZs 925 Ring $4
  • Pale Green Beryl Emerald (Possibly) 10.0 Carat Emerald Rectangular Step Cut 10K G. F. Ring $10
  • 925 Filigree Ring (New) 4 x 2 CM $3
  • CZ 4.0 Carat 925 Ring $2
  • CZ Chips 925 Band $1
  • Sterling Silver Chain Bracelet (New/In Box Retail Value $30) $5
  • Bracelet (Unique Clasp) Heavy 925 8 ½ inches $2
  • Bracelet Light 925 9 ½ inches $1
  • CZ Pendant Necklaces (4) 925 Italy $8
  • CZ Heart Pendant 925 $1
  • 8 Black Freshwater Pearls on Black String Necklace $2 SOLD!
  • 4 Genuine Occluded Emeralds 3.0 Carat Each

My jewelry descriptions are subject to errors as I am learning; so feel free to offer polite corrections in the comments.

I hope you are inspired to invest a small amount of money to find fine thrift store jewelry at thrift stores to turn into big cash.

Related>>>Visit My Etsy Store

Fillable Homestead As A Business Year Planner

  • [caption id="attachment_13461" align="alignleft" width="270"]Fillable Homestead As A Business Year Planner Fillable Homestead As A Business Year Planner[/caption]

    Simplified Printable To Organize Your Homestead Business Off Or Online

    Creating and running your homestead as a business doesn’t have to be challenging or difficult using the Fillable Homestead As A Business Year Planner. It can be a simple and fun process by deciding: (1) what is your niche or cottage industry; (2) what are your business goals; (3) how to fund your business without borrowing; (4) where to sell everywhere online; (5) what is your product and service inventory; (6) what is your marketing and advertising strategy; (7) how much did you earn in weekly sales. It’s easy to get overwhelmed when there is so much information out there to start and operate a homebased business both off and online. I am big on keeping things simple. Therefore, I want to help you strip away all the excess and find what is really important to YOU on your homestead that can earn you money. Once you figure this out, it will be much easier to create a Homestead As A Business Year Planner and stick to it. Just remember to always keep it simple!

    BUY NOW!